A Question About A Specific Case Of Sandhi Of Three Third Tones

by ADMIN 64 views

Introduction

Tone sandhi is a complex phenomenon in the Mandarin Chinese language, where the tones of adjacent syllables change when they are pronounced together. In this article, we will explore a specific case of sandhi involving three successive third tones. This phenomenon is particularly interesting because it challenges the general rules of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese.

Background

In the story by Pu Songling, we learn about a deadly herb called 水莽 (shui3 mang3). According to the story, people who die from this herb may become 水莽鬼 (shui3 mang3 gui3). This mythological concept is fascinating, but it also raises questions about the pronunciation of the word 水莽 (shui3 mang3) and its relation to the sandhi rules in Mandarin Chinese.

Tone Sandhi Rules

Tone sandhi is a rule-based system in Mandarin Chinese, where the tones of adjacent syllables change when they are pronounced together. The general rules of tone sandhi are as follows:

  • When two third tones are adjacent, they change to a second tone.
  • When a third tone is followed by a fourth tone, it changes to a second tone.
  • When a third tone is followed by a first tone, it changes to a second tone.

However, these rules do not seem to apply when three successive third tones are involved. In the case of 水莽 (shui3 mang3), we have three successive third tones, but the sandhi rules do not seem to apply.

The Case of 水莽 (shui3 mang3)

In the story by Pu Songling, the word 水莽 (shui3 mang3) is pronounced with three successive third tones. However, when we apply the general rules of tone sandhi, we would expect the second and third tones to change to a second tone. But this is not the case. The word 水莽 (shui3 mang3) is still pronounced with three successive third tones.

Implications

The case of 水莽 (shui3 mang3) raises interesting implications for the study of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. If three successive third tones do not follow the general rules of tone sandhi, then what are the underlying rules that govern this phenomenon? Is it a special case, or is it a general rule that has not been discovered yet?

Conclusion

In conclusion, the case of 水莽 (shui3 mang3) is a fascinating example of the complexities of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. While the general rules of tone sandhi seem to apply in most cases, there are exceptions that challenge our understanding of this phenomenon. Further research is needed to uncover the underlying rules that govern tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese.

References

  • Pu Songling. (17th century). Liaozhai zhiyi (Strange Stories from a Chinese Studio).
  • Li, R. (2006). Tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. Journal of Chinese Linguistics, 34(2), 241-264.
  • Zhang, J. (2010). Tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese: A corpus-based study. Journal of Phonetics, 38(3), 341-355.

Additional Notes

  • The pronunciation of the word 水莽 (shui3 mang3) is a topic of debate among linguists. Some argue that it is pronounced with three successive third tones, while others argue that it is pronounced with a second tone followed by a third tone.
  • The study of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese is an ongoing area of research, and new discoveries are being made regularly.
  • The case of 水莽 (shui3 mang3) is just one example of the complexities of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. There are many other cases that challenge our understanding of this phenomenon.
    A Question about a Specific Case of Sandhi of Three Third Tones: Q&A ====================================================================

Introduction

In our previous article, we explored a specific case of sandhi involving three successive third tones in the Mandarin Chinese language. This phenomenon is particularly interesting because it challenges the general rules of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. In this article, we will answer some of the most frequently asked questions about this topic.

Q: What is tone sandhi?

A: Tone sandhi is a rule-based system in Mandarin Chinese, where the tones of adjacent syllables change when they are pronounced together. The general rules of tone sandhi are as follows:

  • When two third tones are adjacent, they change to a second tone.
  • When a third tone is followed by a fourth tone, it changes to a second tone.
  • When a third tone is followed by a first tone, it changes to a second tone.

Q: Why do three successive third tones not follow the general rules of tone sandhi?

A: This is a topic of ongoing research, and there is no consensus among linguists on the underlying rules that govern this phenomenon. However, some researchers argue that three successive third tones may be an exception to the general rules of tone sandhi, while others argue that it may be a special case that requires a new set of rules.

Q: What is the pronunciation of the word 水莽 (shui3 mang3)?

A: The pronunciation of the word 水莽 (shui3 mang3) is a topic of debate among linguists. Some argue that it is pronounced with three successive third tones, while others argue that it is pronounced with a second tone followed by a third tone.

Q: What are the implications of this phenomenon for the study of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese?

A: The case of three successive third tones challenges our understanding of the general rules of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. If three successive third tones do not follow the general rules of tone sandhi, then what are the underlying rules that govern this phenomenon? Is it a special case, or is it a general rule that has not been discovered yet?

Q: How does this phenomenon relate to the study of mythological concepts in Chinese culture?

A: The case of three successive third tones is particularly interesting because it relates to the study of mythological concepts in Chinese culture. In the story by Pu Songling, the word 水莽 (shui3 mang3) is associated with a deadly herb that can cause people to become ghosts. This mythological concept is fascinating, and it raises questions about the pronunciation of the word 水莽 (shui3 mang3) and its relation to the sandhi rules in Mandarin Chinese.

Q: What are the future directions for research on this topic?

A: Further research is needed to uncover the underlying rules that govern tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. This may involve studying the pronunciation of words with three successive third tones, as well as exploring the relationship between tone sandhi and mythological concepts in Chinese culture.

Q: What are the practical implications of this phenomenon for language learners and teachers?

A: The case of three successive third tones may have practical implications for language learners and teachers. For example, language learners may need to be aware of the exceptions to the general rules of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese, while language teachers may need to provide additional instruction on the pronunciation of words with three successive third tones.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the case of three successive third tones is a fascinating example of the complexities of tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. While the general rules of tone sandhi seem to apply in most cases, there are exceptions that challenge our understanding of this phenomenon. Further research is needed to uncover the underlying rules that govern tone sandhi in Mandarin Chinese.