bounds And length Restrictions Not Processed In IDSPropertyFacet

by ADMIN 69 views

Describe the bug 📝

In the IDSSpecifications module (see parameter.ts), the logic for processing bounds and length restrictions is commented out. This results in the implementation ignoring these restrictions, leading to incomplete processing of the propertyFacet value.

Expected Behavior: The IDSSpecifications module mapping should properly recognize and process the bounds (and length) restrictions, ensuring that the propertyFacet value is correctly set.

Actual Behavior: Since the code handling these restrictions is commented out, the implementation ignores bounds and length, leading to incomplete processing.

Reproduction ▶️

To reproduce this issue, follow these steps:

const specification = idsSpecs.create("My First IDS!", ["IFC4X3_ADD2", "IFC2X3", "IFC4"]);
const entityFacet = new OBC.IDSEntity(components, {
  type: "simple",
  parameter: ["IfcWall"],
});
const propertyFacet = new OBC.IDSProperty(
  components,
  { type: 'simple', parameter: ['Pset_WallCommom'] },
  { type: 'simple', parameter: 'ThermalTransmittance' }
);
propertyFacet.value = {
  type: 'bounds',
  parameter: {
    min: 2,
    minInclusive: false
  }
};

System Info 💻

The system information is as follows:

"dependencies": {
    "@thatopen/components": "2.4.4",
    "three": "0.160.1"
  }

Used Package Manager 📦

The package manager used is npm.

Error Trace/Logs 📃

No response

Validations ✅

The following validations have been performed:

  • [x] Read the docs.
  • [x] Check that there isn't already an issue that reports the same bug to avoid creating a duplicate.
  • [x] Make sure this is a repository issue and not a framework-specific issue. For example, if it's a THREE.js related bug, it should likely be reported to mrdoob/threejs instead.
  • [x] Check that this is a concrete bug. For Q&A join our Community.
  • [x] The provided reproduction is a minimal reproducible example of the bug.

Impact of the Bug

The impact of this bug is that the propertyFacet value is not being processed correctly, leading to incomplete data. This can cause issues downstream in the application, particularly when working with complex data structures.

Solution

To solve this issue, the commented-out code in the IDSSpecifications module needs to be uncommented and properly implemented. This will ensure that the bounds and length restrictions are processed correctly, resulting in accurate propertyFacet values.

Implementation

The implementation of the solution involves uncommenting the code in the IDSSpecifications module and making the necessary changes to ensure that the bounds and length restrictions are processed correctly. This may involve adding new logic or modifying existing code to accommodate the requirements.

Testing

To ensure that the solution is working correctly, thorough testing should be performed. This includes testing the propertyFacet value with different bounds and length restrictions to verify that it is being processed correctly.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the issue of bounds and length restrictions not being processed in IDSPropertyFacet is a critical bug that needs to be addressed. By uncommenting the code in the IDSSpecifications module and implementing the necessary changes, the propertyFacet value can be processed correctly, resulting in accurate data. Thorough testing should be performed to ensure that the solution is working correctly.

Future Work

Future work involves continuing to improve the IDSSpecifications module to ensure that it is processing data correctly. This may involve adding new features or modifying existing code to accommodate changing requirements.

Related Issues

Related issues include:

  • Issue 1: This issue reports a similar bug in the IDSSpecifications module.
  • Issue 2: This issue reports a bug in the IDSPropertyFacet class.

References

References include:

  • Docs: This document provides an introduction to the IDSSpecifications module.
  • Parameter.ts: This file contains the code for the IDSSpecifications module.
  • IDSPropertyFacet: This file contains the code for the IDSPropertyFacet class.
    bounds and length restrictions not processed in IDSPropertyFacet ================================================================================

Q&A

Q: What is the issue with the IDSSpecifications module?

A: The issue is that the logic for processing bounds and length restrictions is commented out, resulting in the implementation ignoring these restrictions and leading to incomplete processing of the propertyFacet value.

Q: What is the expected behavior of the IDSSpecifications module?

A: The expected behavior is that the module should properly recognize and process the bounds (and length) restrictions, ensuring that the propertyFacet value is correctly set.

Q: What is the actual behavior of the IDSSpecifications module?

A: The actual behavior is that the module ignores bounds and length, leading to incomplete processing.

Q: How can I reproduce this issue?

A: To reproduce this issue, follow the steps outlined in the reproduction section. This involves creating a specification, entity facet, and property facet, and setting the property facet value to a bounds type with a minimum value of 2 and minInclusive set to false.

Q: What system information is required to reproduce this issue?

A: The system information required is the dependencies and package manager used. In this case, the dependencies are @thatopen/components and three, and the package manager is npm.

Q: What are the validations that have been performed to ensure this is a valid bug?

A: The following validations have been performed:

  • Read the docs
  • Check that there isn't already an issue that reports the same bug
  • Make sure this is a repository issue and not a framework-specific issue
  • Check that this is a concrete bug
  • The provided reproduction is a minimal reproducible example of the bug

Q: What is the impact of this bug?

A: The impact of this bug is that the propertyFacet value is not being processed correctly, leading to incomplete data. This can cause issues downstream in the application, particularly when working with complex data structures.

Q: How can this bug be solved?

A: This bug can be solved by uncommenting the code in the IDSSpecifications module and making the necessary changes to ensure that the bounds and length restrictions are processed correctly.

Q: What testing should be performed to ensure the solution is working correctly?

A: Thorough testing should be performed to ensure that the solution is working correctly. This includes testing the propertyFacet value with different bounds and length restrictions to verify that it is being processed correctly.

Q: What are the related issues to this bug?

A: The related issues are:

  • Issue 1: This issue reports a similar bug in the IDSSpecifications module.
  • Issue 2: This issue reports a bug in the IDSPropertyFacet class.

Q: What references are available for further information?

A: The references available are:

  • Docs: This document provides an introduction to the IDSSpecifications module.
  • Parameter.ts: This file contains the code for the IDSSpecifications module.
  • IDSPropertyFacet: This file contains the code for the IDSPropertyFacet class.

Additional Questions

Q: Can you provide more information on the IDSSpecifications module?

A: The IDSSpecifications module is a part of the IDSSpecifications package, which provides a set of specifications for working with data. The module is responsible for processing the data and ensuring that it is in the correct format.

Q: Can you provide more information on the IDSPropertyFacet class?

A: The IDSPropertyFacet class is a part of the IDSPropertyFacet package, which provides a set of classes for working with properties. The class is responsible for processing the property facet value and ensuring that it is in the correct format.

Q: Can you provide more information on the bounds and length restrictions?

A: The bounds and length restrictions are used to limit the range of values that can be assigned to a property. The bounds restriction specifies the minimum and maximum values that can be assigned, while the length restriction specifies the maximum length of the value.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the issue of bounds and length restrictions not being processed in IDSPropertyFacet is a critical bug that needs to be addressed. By understanding the issue, reproducing it, and solving it, we can ensure that the propertyFacet value is processed correctly and that the application works as expected.